BEIJING — The 10 middle-aged officials who gathered in a nondescript government office in southwestern China last month were assigned a highly fraught mission: Highlight one another's faults and confess any transgressions that might undermine the Communist Party's credibility among the masses.
Officially, at least, nothing was off limits. Superiors could be criticized, a colleague's affinity for expensive jewelry was fair game, and even voicing opposition to the central leadership's policies was permitted.
The chief of the officials' bureau spoke first, confessing that he was "a little hasty and might push others too hard," recalled one attendee who asked not to be identified to avoid retribution. When it came time for the rest of those present to speak, each carefully imitated the chief's innocuous critique in a pantomime of remorse that conveniently left everyone unscathed.
"There's no guarantee what you say in the meeting won't be used against you in the future, so the best way to avoid problems is to follow the leader," the official explained afterward in a phone interview.
Wielded with often violent results in the days when Mao Zedong was China's paramount leader, "criticism and self-criticism" sessions have been resurrected by President Xi Jinping as "the most powerful weapon" for rallying the Communist Party and the Chinese people behind his push to liberalize the economy while fortifying the party's control over this nation of 1.3 billion people.
The sessions are officially known as "democratic life" meetings for their ostensibly open atmosphere — though they take place behind closed doors. The meetings, a crucial element of Mr. Xi's so-called mass-line campaign, are intended to bolster the party's legitimacy among a public increasingly disgusted by official graft, gross mismanagement and unseemly activities that involve sex, overpriced liquor or luxury watches, or sometimes all three. In the year since Mr. Xi came to power, cadres have been encouraged to "experience the grass-roots" difficulties of everyday life while yielding to a crackdown on extravagance and other perks of officialdom, according to pronouncements in the state news media.
Resolutely opposed to subjecting the party to the rule of law and potentially undermining its hold on power, Mr. Xi, analysts say, is selling the self-criticism campaign as a substitute capable of taming official malfeasance and inoculating the party against the possibility of political unrest.
"It's using an ideological tightening to prevent the kind of explosion of political participation that could be triggered by a more relaxed environment," said Xiao Gongqin, a history professor at Shanghai Normal University.
But critics say the campaign is at best superficial, and at worst a dangerous revival of Maoist tactics that in an earlier era brought the nation to its knees. For many Chinese of a certain age, criticism and self-criticism sessions are synonymous with public humiliation and brutal punishment. The party has sporadically revived the practice in a more casual form, though not since the decade-long Cultural Revolution that ended in 1976 has a Chinese leader invested so much political capital in such patently ideological pageantry.
"For Xi to pick up the method used by Mao 40 years ago shows how desperate he is to keep party members under control," said Huang Jing, a professor at the National University of Singapore who specializes in Chinese politics. But in refusing to liberalize politically as he attempts major economic changes, President Xi could scuttle his chances for long-term success, Mr. Huang said. "You can't walk with one leg going north and one leg going south," he said.
Despite Mr. Xi's decree that officials use self-criticism sessions to "look in the mirror, straighten their attire, take a bath and seek remedies," as he said last June, according to the state news agency Xinhua, some say the meetings offer officials a way to avoid any of that.
Chris Buckley contributed reporting from Hong Kong. Patrick Zuo, Mia Li and Frank Ye contributed research from Beijing.
Anda sedang membaca artikel tentang
China Revives Mao-Era Self-Criticism, but This Kind Bruises Few Egos
Dengan url
https://dunialuasekali.blogspot.com/2013/12/china-revives-mao-era-self-criticism.html
Anda boleh menyebar luaskannya atau mengcopy paste-nya
China Revives Mao-Era Self-Criticism, but This Kind Bruises Few Egos
namun jangan lupa untuk meletakkan link
China Revives Mao-Era Self-Criticism, but This Kind Bruises Few Egos
sebagai sumbernya
0 komentar:
Posting Komentar